California HSR should use Tejon Pass

The current California HSR plan has significant flaws; a major mistake was selecting a detour via Palmdale instead of the direct route via I-5 across Tejon pass to connect Bakersfield to Los Angeles. The cost of the Palmdale route -- about $32 billion in current dollars -- is more than twice that of the direct link, and nobody wants to pay for it. The HSR project will be restricted to the Central Valley until the less expensive Tejon route is embraced.

Tuesday, August 4, 2020

Federal ARRA award to CHSR in 2010

The California High Speed Rail (CHSR) project was initiated in November 2008 with the approval of Proposition 1A by a majority of 52,6% of the yes-no vote on the measure (7.6% of the ballots were blank or invalid, so the yes vote was only 48.6% of all votes cast). The stated intent of Prop 1A was "to initiate the construction of a high-speed train system that connects the San Francisco Transbay Terminal to Los Angeles Union Station and Anaheim, and links the state’s major population centers," authorizing $9 billion in state bonds for HSR and $950 million for supporting, conventional rail service. $8.1 B was specifically reserved for HSR construction, and was clearly intended to leverage outside support for a initial project some three or four times larger. Additional state support is not authorized by Prop. 1A, but it is not ruled out either.

Barack Obama was elected U.S. President in November 2008, and in February 2009 Congress passed and Obama signed the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) which included $8 B for infrastructure improvements to intercity rail with priority for HSR projects. On Qctober 1, 2009, the CHSR Authority submitted six application for federal funding under this program, two for planning and four for ifrastructure projects:

  • NEPA/CEQA for Phase 2: Merced-Sacramento & L.A.-San Diego ... $60.0 million
  • NEPA/CEQA for Altamont Corridor ... $22.5 M
  • Complete design and construction of 50-mile segment, San Francisco-San Jose ... $980.0 M
  • Complete design and construction of 50-mile segment, Merced-Fresno ... $466.0 M
  • Complete design and construction of 98-mile segment, Fresno-Bakersfield ... $819.5 M
  • Complete design and construction of of 30-mile segment, L.A.-Anaheim ... $2,187.5 M
CHSRA offered an equal (50%) match for each of these projects. The total request was for $4,535.5 M, over half of the available funds for the HSIPR program. "On January 28, 2010, the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) announced the selection of CHSRA to receive up to $2.25 billion in ARRA funds for environmental clearance and supporting preliminary engineering for Phase 1 and funding for certain CHSRA design-build Project Sections." The amount was subsequently increased to $2.55 B when other states declined their awards, with the Authority committing a minimum match of $2.51 B, and further augmented by a supplemental "2010" award of $929 M, with a match of $360 M. CHSRA proposed to draw all of the local match ($2.87 B) from Prop. 1A bonds.

The Grant Agreement for the initial ARRA award for $2.47 B was signed in December 2010 (increased to $2.55 B in August 2011), and the agreement for the "2010" award for $929 M was signed in November 2011. In the meantime, there were extensive negotiations about the scope of the work, complicated by a growing realization that CHSRA had woefully underestimated construction costs in its 2005 program-level EIR which the application was based on. It was in the interest of both CHSRA and USDOT to build the longest possible segment, and they settled on Madera-Shafter, some 119 miles, pegged at a cost of $5.8 B with CHSRA absorbing any additional costs. USDOT recognized that full HSR operations on this segment were not feasible until connected to a larger system, so non-electric San Joaquin service on the CVS was accepted as a satisfactory interim alternative. With construction of this segment now half complete, the cost is currently estimated at $12.4 B, relying on an additional state contribution of some $7 B from Greenhouse Gas Cap & Trade revenues.

Completion date for the ARRA award was originally Sept. 30, 2017, later extended to Dec. 31, 2022, although the federal grant still had to be spent before the first date. Completion date for the "2010" award was originally Dec. 31, 2018, later also extended to Dec. 31, 2022. USDOT allowed CHSRA to spend ARRA funds in advance of the local match, unusual for a grant of this nature, but this leniency was not extended to the "2010" award. In May 2019 none of this grant had yet been spent, and the Trump administration formally withdrew the award.

References

No comments:

Post a Comment