California HSR should use Tejon Pass

The current California HSR plan has significant flaws; a major mistake was selecting a detour via Palmdale instead of the direct route via I-5 across Tejon pass to connect Bakersfield to Los Angeles. The cost of the Palmdale route -- about $32 billion in current dollars -- is more than twice that of the direct link, and nobody wants to pay for it. The HSR project will be restricted to the Central Valley until the less expensive Tejon route is embraced.

Timeline for Calif. HSR

Prior to the 1990, there appears to have been little interest in a state-wide HSR system in California. There were, however, two earlier, less ambitious efforts floated in the 1980's. In 1982 there was an attempt in the CA state legislature to fund HSR between Los Angeles and San Diego (Trainor 2009), and in 1985-86 a Las Vegas group sponsored a study of HSR linking Las Vegas and Ontario (UPI 1986). Neither effort gained any traction.

AB971 Study Group (March 1990). This may be the first state-sponsored study to consider a state-wide HSR system for California. Consultant: PBQD. Strongly recommended a phased approach, by first constructing the Tehachapi crossing via the Grapevine (I-5) combined with major improvements to the San Joaquin train service by increasing speeds to 110 or 125 mph. Later upgrading to HSR (185 mph), with access to the Bay Area via either Panoche Pass or Altamont Pass.

Rail connection between LAX and airport in Palmdale (c. 1990). Proposals for an international airport in Palmdale date to the 1960s, and Los Angeles County proposed to develop the area adjacent to the proposed site in 1970. There has also been interest in using the existing Palmdale airport as a satellite to LAX, and there was an effort by LACTC around 1990 to find a private partner to build a rail link between the two airports. No potential partner was willing to contribute as much financial support as the County required, and the effort died.

Preliminary engineering study for Los Angeles-Bakersfield HSR (Aug. 1994). For Caltrans, consultant PBQD. Two versions: full report (241 pp) and summary report (83 pp). The interest in connecting Palmdale and LAX with HSR evidently induced Caltrans to include the Palmdale route as an alternative in this engineering study. Largely qualitative overview of the most promising alignments, for both I-5 and Palmdale routes. Segment between Santa Clarita and Palmdale closely follows Soledad canyon. Stress put on potential growth in Antelope valley, including LAX satellite airport in Palmdale. Suggests that “very aggressive” grades (5%) are feasible, but less tunneling doesn't save money!?, on I-5 route. This study evidently provided the basis for the alignments considered in the 2005 Program EIR, and the basis for asserting that the two alignments had nearly equal capital costs (see Table 6-1, summary report).
    “Impacts of Public Comment on the Feasibility Study. The evaluation revealed several issues that prompted public support, issues that tended to be ore pertinent to public policy than to technical analysis. … [One] issue germane to public policy was the strong support for the alignments to accommodate growing population centers, even if this increased the travel time between Los Angeles and the Bay Area. “ (ibid, p. 69).
    “Grade. … [O]nly the very aggressive VHS/HS options (5.0% grade) for the I-5 route enable the Garlock fault to be crossed at grade. This fault is considered to be the greatesr seismic hazard for the Los Angeles-Bakersfield corridor.” (ibid, p. 78))

High-Speed Rail Summary Report and Action Plan (Draft Sept. 1996, Final Dec. 1996). Intercity High-Speed Rail Commission, principal consultant Cambridge Systematics. May have used PBQD 1994 study for Los Angeles-Bakersfield section, but also studied and rejected a “California Aquaduct” alignment located between I-5 and Palmdale routes. Draft recommended I-5 and Altamont alignments, but final recommended Palmdale and Altamont.
    “Southern Mountain Pass. The Commission recommends the I-5 (Grapevine) option for crossing the Tehachapi Mountains north of Los Angels, over the Mojave and Aqueduct options, either of which could serve Palmdale and the Antelope Valley. Although requiring more aggressive engineering solutions to deal with steep grades and earthquake faults, the Grapevine option is potentially the least costly and produces greater ridership and revenue. The greater intercity ridership gained by serving the Palmdale area is offset by the ridership lost due to increased travel time, This recommendation would be reconsidered if local contributions were able to significantly offset the additional costs or if other economic advantages from serving the longer Palmdale route become apparent.” (Draft, p. ES-6)
    “Southern Mountain Pass. The Commission recommends an Antelope Valley alignment for crossing the Tehachapi Mountains north of Los Angels, instead of the I-5 (Grapevine) option. This recommendation is conditioned on the expectation that local contributions will significantly offset the additional costs and/or that there are considerable economic advantages to serving the longer Antelope Valley/Palmdale route.” (Final, p. ES-7)

California High Speed Rail Authority (Sept. 24, 1996). Established by S.B. 1420, Chapter 796 of the California Statutes of 1996. Bill introduced by Kopp and Costa.

Draft Business Plan, CHSR Authority (Jan. 2000). Map on front endsheet shows both Palmdale and I-5 alignments, map on back endsheet shows I-5 as part of “Highest Return on Investment Route.” Discussion in Sect. 2.1, “Tehachapi Crossing: Union Station – Bakersfield”:
    From Union Station to Santa Clarita the Metrolink right-of-way will be utilized with potential stations at Burbank Airport and Santa Clarita. North of this, one of the major challenges to a state-wide high speed system is the connection from Santa Clarita to Bakersfield. Two viable options for this corridor exist. One follows Interstate 5 (I-5) over the Grapevine, which includes 28 miles of tunnels, while the other is a line through the Antelope Valley with a station at Palmdale. The Antelope Valley alignment, which crosses the Tehachapis through the Mojave Pass, will be 41 miles longer than the I-5 route option but includes only 11 miles of tunnels.
    Engineering and planning analyses by the Authority, the High Speed Rail Commission, and Caltrans show that both options are feasible. Based on the results of engineering and other analyses to date, the I-5 Corridor would cost $700 million less to construct and produce higher ridership with lower operating costs. Therefore, the Authority, using cost and ridership as its primary criteria, selected the I-5 route to be used for the funding scenario.
    The Authority recognizes, however, that the I-5 route decision may change as a result of further technical studies and analyses performed during the environmental process, along with other factors, including but not limited to airport development, changes in regional growth patterns, and cost sharing with local entities, developers or airports. Therefore, the Authority recommends that both corridors be evaluated equally through the environmental assessment phase and that final selection of a preferred alignment be made at the conclusion of that phase.
    Table 2.1 / Capital Costs by Segment: Los Angeles – Bakersfield / 110 miles / $4.4 billion / $40.4 million per mile

California High-Speed Rail Program EIR/EIS (Aug. 2005). Prepared by California High Speed Rail Authority, with PBQD as the principal (lead) consultant. Selected Palmdale route as the preferred alternative in the south, and identified Pachaco Pass as the preferred alternative in the north subject to review in a Supplemental EIR.
    “The alignment through the SR-58/Soledad Canyon Corridor (Antelope Valley) with an HST station at Palmdale is the preferred option for crossing the Tehachapi Mountains between the Central Valley and Southern California. Although the longer Antelope Valley alignment would add about 10 minutes to express service travel times between northern and southern California and have less intercity ridership potential (trips between regions) than the I-5 alignment option, it would have fewer potential environmental impacts, it would be less subject to seismic activity and have considerably less tunneling and thereby have fewer constructability issues, and would increase connectivity and accessibility. ...
    “The Antelope Valley alignment traverses less challenging terrain than the I-5 options, which would result considerably less tunneling overall (13 miles [21 km] of tunneling for the Antelope Valley option versus 23 [37 km] miles for I-5 options), and considerably shorter tunnels (maximum length of 3.4 miles [5.5 km] for the Antelope Valley option versus two tunnels greater than 5 miles [8 km] for the I-5 options) which would result in fewer constructability issues. Although the Antelope Valley option is about 35 miles longer than the I-5 alignment options, it is estimated to be slightly less expensive to construct as a result of less tunneling through the Tehachapi Mountains. In addition, due to its more gentle gradient, geology, topology and other features, the SR-58/Soledad Canyon Corridor offers greater opportunities for using potential HST alignment variations, particularly through the mountainous areas of the corridor, to avoid impacts to environmental resources. In contrast, the more challenging terrain of the I-5 Corridor greatly limits the ability to avoid sensitive resources and seismic constraints. The alignment optimization system (Quantm) that was utilized to identify and evaluate approximately 12 million alignment options for each mountain crossing could only find one practicable alignment option through the Tehachapi Mountains for the I-5 Corridor.” (Final EIR, p. 6A-18)
    “Comments from the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) and the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) on the Draft Program EIR/EIS stated concerns regarding potential impacts to the Santa Clara River through the Soledad Canyon portion the Antelope Valley alignment. The Program EIR/EIS defines Soledad Canyon as a 'relatively wide corredor area that includes both the SR-14 and UPRR alignments between the Antelope Valley and Santa Clarita” (Section 2.6.9C). Future study of the Antelope Valley alignment would consider an option that closely follows the SR-14 through Soledad Canyon as an avoidance option for potential impacts in the Santa Clara River. ...” (ibid, p. 6A-19)

Proposition 1. Safe, Reliable High-Speed Passenger Train Bond Act for the 21st Century (Sept. 19, 2008). SB 1856, Costa. Replaced by Prop. 1A one week later (see below).

Proposition 1A. Safe, Reliable High-Speed Passenger Train Bond Act for the 21st Century (Nov. 4, 2008). AB 3034, enacted Sept. 26, 2008. Replaced Prop. 1 (see above).
2704.04. (a) It is the intent of the Legislature by enacting this chapter and of the people of California by approving the bond measure pursuant to this chapter to initiate the construction of a high-speed train system that connects the San Francisco Transbay Terminal to Los Angeles Union Station and Anaheim, and links the state’s major population centers, including Sacramento, the San Francisco Bay Area, the Central Valley, Los Angeles, the Inland Empire, Orange County, and San Diego consistent with the authority’s certified environmental impact reports of November 2005 and July 9, 2008. ...
(b)(3) Upon a finding by the authority that expenditure of bond proceeds for capital costs in corridors other than the corridor described in paragraph (2) would advance the construction of the system, would be consistent with the criteria described in subdivision (f) of Section 2704.08, and would not have an adverse impact on the construction of Phase 1 of the high-speed train project, the authority may request funding for capital costs, and the Legislature may appropriate funds described in paragraph (1) in the annual Budget Act, to be expended for any of the following high-speed train corridors:
(A) Sacramento to Stockton to Fresno.
(B) San Francisco Transbay Terminal to San Jose to Fresno.
(C) Oakland to San Jose.
(D) Fresno to Bakersfield to Palmdale to Los Angeles Union Station.
(E) Los Angeles Union Station to Riverside to San Diego.
(F) Los Angeles Union Station to Anaheim to Irvine.
(G) Merced to Stockton to Oakland and San Francisco via the Altamont Corridor. ...
2704.07. The authority shall pursue and obtain other private and public funds, including, but not limited to, federal funds, funds from revenue bonds, and local funds, to augment the proceeds of this chapter."

Voter Guide, Argument in favor of Proposition 1A (Nov. 4, 2008). "Proposition 1A will protect taxpayer interests.

  • Public oversight and detailed independent review of financing plans.
  • Matching private and federal funding to be identified BEFORE state bond funds are spent.
  • 90% of the bond funds to be spent on system construction, not more studies, plans, and engineering activities.
  • Bond financing to be available to every part of the state.
  • The most cost-efficient construction segments to have the highest priority."

American Recovery and Reinvestment Act’s (ARRA) High-Speed Intercity Passenger Rail Program (HSIPR) Application (Oct. 1, 2009). California High-Speed Rail Authority.
The CHSR Authority submitted seven applications for federal funding under this program, three for planning and four for infrastructure projects. A equal local match was offered for each proposal, so the total cost was double the requested grant amount.

  • NEPA/CEQA for Phase 1: San Francisco-Anaheim ... $194.0 million
  • NEPA/CEQA for Phase 2: Merced-Sacramento & L.A.-San Diego ... $60.0 million
  • NEPA/CEQA for Altamont Corridor ... $22.5 M
  • Complete design and construction of 50-mile segment, San Francisco-San Jose ... $980.0 M
  • Complete design and construction of 50-mile segment, Merced-Fresno ... $466.0 M
  • Complete design and construction of 98-mile segment, Fresno-Bakersfield ... $819.5 M
  • Complete design and construction of of 30-mile segment, L.A.-Anaheim ... $2,187.5 M

High-Speed Rail Grants Announced; California, Florida, and Illinois Are Lucky Recipients (January 28, 2010).  Yonah Freemark, The Transport Politic.
      "After months of speculation about which states will get funding from the Federal Railroad Administration to begin construction on new high-speed corridors, the news is in. As has been expected, California, Florida, and Illinois are the big winners, with more than one billion in spending proposed for each.
      "California voters committed $10 billion in taxes to a high-speed line between San Francisco and Anaheim in November 2008, and their unrivaled effort has been justly rewarded, with a commitment of $2.25 billion to the project, about half of what the state applied for in August. ...Roughly one hundred million more would go to improvements on existing Amtrak corridors throughout the state, including a large expansion of San Jose’s Diridon Station and 110 mph trains on the Pacific Surfliner between San Diego and Los Angeles. ...
      "Florida ... will get a large infusion of money as well: $1.25 billion. ... Illinois, ... [w]ith $1.133 billion, ... will be able to afford significant upgrades to the line [between Chicago and St. Louis] on the way to 110 mph service, decreasing travel times from 5h30 to 4h00. Missouri will get some of those funds for upgraded and more reliable operations between St. Louis and Kansas City. $823 million will go to new train service from Chicago to Madison, Wisconsin and $244 million to an upgraded corridor to Detroit."

FRA Grant/Cooperative Agreement for ARRA Funding ($2.27B) (Dec. 29, 2010). CHSRA. Amendment 1 to prior Agreement FR-HSR-0009-10-01-00, followed by five subsequent amendments, the last dated May 18, 2016. The total federal award under this agreement was $2.552 billion.

FRA Grant/Cooperative Agreement for FY 10 Funding (Nov 18, 2011). CHSRA. Agreement FR-HSR-01118-12-01-00, for a federal award of $928.6 million. CHSRA was unable to spend any of this award, and in 2018 the Trump administraton withdrew it.

California High Speed Rail Program: Revised 2012 Business Plan (Apr. 2012). CHSRA, Principal consultant PBQD. Accompanied by two technical reports:

  • “Ridership and Revenue Forecasting,” by Cambridge Systematics, Inc., Oct. 19, 2011.
  • “Cost changes from 2009 Report to 2012 Business Plan Capital Cost Estimates,” by Parsons Brinckerhoff, Draft Oct. 2011. (Detailed explanation of cost increases from 2003 EIR.)

Senate Bill No. 1029, Budget Act of 2012. (July 18, 2012). Athorization to start construction of HSR in the Central Valley, allocating $3.241 B from the federal ARRA and FY 10 grants (Sec. 8) and $2.609 B from Prop. 1A bonds (Sec. 9). In addition, $1.1 B from Prop. 1A bonds was allocated for local assistance in the bookends (Sec. 3).

California State Rail Plan (2018). Caltrans, Principal consultant AECOM.

California High Speed Rail: Draft 2020 Business Plan (Feb. 12, 2020). CHSRA, Principal consultant DB E&C USA (Deutsche Bahn AG, Engineering & Consulting). Accompanied by a number of reports:
Technical Reports

  • 50-Year Lifecycle Capital Cost Model Documentation
  • Capital Cost Basis of Estimate Report
  • High, Medium and Low Cash Flow Analysis
  • Operations and Maintenance Cost Model Documentation
  • Ridership and Revenue Forecasting
  • Service Planning Methodology
  • Ridership and Revenue Risk Analysis
  • Ridership and Revenue Model
Supplemental Reports
  • Business Case Assessment Study
  • Central Valley Segment System Management Operations Interim Financial Plan
  • Side by Side Study - Quantitative Report
  • 2019 Equivalent Capacity Analysis Report

No comments:

Post a Comment