“Proposal for planning grant for area surrounding new Intercontinemtal Jet Airport [in] Palmdale, California.” Los Angeles County, California, Aug. 1970.
“Palmdale International Airport, New Airport: Environmental Impact Statement, Volume 1.” United States. Federal Aviation Administration, Feb. 1979.
“Study says high-speed trains from L.A. to Las Vegas feasible,” United Press International, Sept. 29, 1986.
LOS ANGELES After 18 months of study, proponents of high-speed train service to Las Vegas have announced a series of 'briefings' on the futuristic system.
The study, sponsored by Las Vegas, concluded that a high-speed train would be technologically and economically feasible and environmentally safe.
Supporters of the project that would whisk travelers across the desert at speeds up to 300 mph hope to convince Southern Californians the venture is a good idea.
Chip Jacobs, “LAX-Palmdale railway mired in confusion.” Los Angeles Business Journal (Vol. 14, Issue 4), Jan. 27, 1992.
“Hopes of making a $4 billion, high-speed rail line between Los Angeles and Palmdale the first privately built mass transit project in the Southland appear to be making a U-turn, with the project's fate increasingly tied to the availability of public funding, transit officials conceded last week. …
“ 'We're concerned that there might be too much public money and not enough private,' said Jack Bacharach, a board member of the Los Angeles County Transportation Commission, which is overseeing the proposed project between L.A. International Airport and Palmdale Airport. 'If that's the case, the line may not make it.' ...
“The LACTC has tentatively earmarked $1.2 billion for the LAX-Palmdale train, which would likely travel on a north-south route down the median of the Golden State (5) and Antelope Valley (114) freeways when construction is finished at decade's end. Last July, when the commission approved requests-for-proposals from 14 bidders, talk of subsidies centered on paying back preliminary engineering costs. ...”
Federal Railroad Administration, "High speed ground transportation for America." U.S. Department of Transportation, 1997.
Systematic evaluation of the viability of HSR in about ten corridors in the U.S., including California North-South (San Francisco-Los Angeles-San Diego) and California South (Los Angeles-San Diego). Most corridors are evaluated for eight scenarios, based on maximum speed: 90 mph and 110 mph (conventional diesel), 125 mph and 150 mph (conventional diesel and electric), 200 mph (electric HSR), and 300 mph (Maglev).
Louis Galvan, “Costa tells high-speed rail groups to get on the same track.” The Fresno Bee, Apr. 11, 1999.
“Speaking at a meeting of about 24 members of the Rail Passenger Association of California, with two representatives of the Train Riders Association also attending, Costa encouraged the two groups to get together and work on carrying the message to Davis through their elected representatives in Sacramento.
“ 'We ha
ve to educate him [Davis] on what's going on,' Costa said.
“Davis last month told reporters the state does not need a multibillion-dollar ''Buck Rogers'' bullet train to run through the Valley and that he would rather see rail funds spent on fast commuter trains near urban areas.”
Russell Clemings, “Group gives tentative OK to high-speed rail.” The Fresno Bee, Dec. 16, 1999.
“The authority's recommended route would run from San Diego through Temecula to Riverside, then go west to Union Station in Los Angeles, and from there cross the Tehachapis and enter the San Joaquin Valley via the I-5 corridor.
“The route would then trace Highway 99 through Fresno to Sacramento. Another line would branch off toward Los Banos, crossing Pacheco Pass to reach Gilroy, San Jose and San Francisco. “
Larry Miller, “High-speed rail could put Fresno in a sweet spot.” The Fresno Bee, July 7, 2001.
“Fastest route: The route that the authority proposed is known as the Aqueduct Route. For nearly eight decades rail planners have advocated the route as the fastest, flattest and shortest rail connection possible between Southern California and the Central Valley. It would link the existing rail head at Palmdale (which may become the site of an expanded Los Angeles International Airport) with Bakersfield, where all passenger rail lines end in the Valley and where freight lines begin their slow, circuitous steep climb across the Tehachapi Mountains. The Aqueduct Route could save enormous amounts of money in wasted energy costs, and would provide immediate benefits for not only higher speed passenger rail, but Amtrak and rail freight as well.
“Absent such a connection, cash-strapped Amtrak, for example, has recently begun promoting an upgrade of its coastal route between Los Angeles and San Francisco. That move would further isolate the Valley from California's future and further emphasize the economic and political separation between Northern, Southern and Central California.”
Lesli A. Maxwell, “High-speed rail debate eases Lawmakers' cool reaction appears to derail plans to merge project authority, Caltrans.” The Fresno Bee, Apr. 7, 2003. (This article is interesting, HSR folks insisted on autonomy.)
https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=T004&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm¤tPosition=37&docId=GALE%7CA99997460&docType=Article&sort=Relevance&contentSegment=ZNEW-FullText&prodId=STND&contentSet=GALE%7CA99997460&searchId=R1&userGroupName=sacr16736&inPS=true
SACRAMENTO -- The turf battle that broke out in January over which state agency ultimately will build and run a 700-mile bullet train system in California is showing signs of simmering down.
Gov. Davis' cost-saving proposal to move the High Speed Rail Authority into the state Department of Transportation set off two months of sniping, mostly from critics who said the merger would doom an upcoming $9.95 billion bond measure to build the train system's first phase.
Davis officials say the proposal would save $600,000 in staff salaries and benefits -- a sliver of the Democratic governor's solution to a budget shortfall that could reach $35 billion over 15 months. ...
It was Florez's bill -- which is more than a counter to Davis' plan with its call to create a new agency to manage high-speed rail and passenger rail lines managed now by Caltrans -- that stirred the conflict.
Florez argues that Caltrans shouldn't have authority over any rail projects because of its poor record in overseeing Amtrak lines such as the San Joaquin route between Sacramento and Bakersfield. ...
Morshed said in an interview that it makes sense to tap Caltrans resources and expertise, especially during tight budget years. His main concern over a transfer is how the rail authority would be able to direct a staff that is employed by Caltrans.
"The biggest question about this proposal is governance," Morshed said. "Who makes the ultimate decision?" ...
Some rail advocates hope the governor's proposal sticks, saying it may help take some of the politics out of the bullet train project.
"We think this is well-intended," said Ken Gosting, a member of a group known as Transportation Involves Everyone. "[Davis] is breaking up a club. To move it to Caltrans breaks up the chummy, political atmosphere."
All nine members of the rail authority are political appointees. Diridon, a Davis appointee, was criticized last year when he hosted a fund-raiser for the governor's campaign one day after the Democrat approved the bond measure.
Florez's mother, Fran Florez, was appointed to the authority last year by Senate President John Burton, D-San Francisco. ...
The bond is set for the November 2004 ballot.
Richard Trainor, “Paradise Lost? High-Speed Trains Get Waylaid, Shady Politicians Get Billions, and Taxpayers Get the Shaft!” 2009. (See Chap. 4, pp 23-35 for the 1982 effort to start HSR connecting Los Angeles and San Diego.)
Ed Fuentes, "Return of Proposed High-Speed Rail Route Could Threaten Connection to Las Vegas." KCET (Los Angeles), May 4, 2011. (Article on proposal by CHSRA staff to revisit I-5 alignment, and very negative response from Palmdale.)
https://www.kcet.org/socal-focus/return-of-proposed-grapevine-high-speed-rail-route-could-threaten-connection-to-las
Hop onto the California High-Speed Rail Authority's website and you'll see that the route whisks passengers between Los Angeles and Bakersfield with a between in the Antelope Valley. Now an older plan to run the train over the Grapevine has resurfaced, threatening a key transportation connection and a city protesting.
Minutes before a Wednesday hearing held in Sacramento, California High-Speed Rail Authority spokesperson Rachel Wall said the request to review studies of the I-5 route through the Grapevine was a budget precaution. "We are asking the board to approve a look at it," she explained.
The Grapevine route, first shelved in 2005 due to projected costs from tunneling and seismic risks, is now countered by time travel estimates.
"A preliminary look at the Grapevine indicated a potential to reduce the route by 25 miles, saving 7 to 9 minutes of travel time to San Francisco from Los Angeles," said Wall. "It's possible that this alternative could save more than $1 billion."
With terse words and a slew of data, Palmdale officials will present economic forecasts showing the Antelope Valley proposed route linking the Central Valley with Los Angeles--and a station in Palmdale--will benefit the California.
"We want to be pro-active," said John Mlynar, Communications Manager for the city of Palmdale. "North Los Angeles County is the one region that can handle potential growth. We have open land."
"It is outrageous to think that after all the studying and all the evidence that points to the fact that the route through the Antelope Valley is the most economical, sensible and efficient route, the CHSRA would even consider changing the route," City Manager Steve Williams pointed out in a statement. "It is absurd to make this kind of investment without including the Antelope Valley, which currently makes up 10 percent of the ridership."
Also at stake is the city of Palmdale becoming a major transportation hub for Southern California. "When you combine high-speed rail with the High Desert Corridor [highway], DesertXpress rail [to Las Vegas] and the Palmdale regional airport, it will have an immense positive economic impact."
Still, by late Wednesday afternoon, the authority's Operations Committee approved the staff recommendation to begin a conceptual study reintroducing the Grapevine alignment "to evaluate its potential feasibility," according to CHSRA CEO Roelof van Ark. The same recommendation will be made to the full CHSRA board Thursday.
[Update, May 5th: The board approved beginning a conceptual study of the alternate alignment following Interstate 5 over the Grapevine.]
Palmdale, however, will not budge. They will speak again, said Mlynar. So will Tejon Ranch stakeholders and the National Wildlife Conservancy, who also today spoke to protest the return of the Grapevine route.
Michael Cabanatuan (Staff Writer), "Roelof van Ark, high-speed rail CEO, resigns ... Chairman of authority's board also stepping aside." [SF] Chronicle, Jan. 13, 2012, updated Jan. 12, 2012, 8:45 p.m.
https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Roelof-van-Ark-high-speed-rail-CEO-resigns-2501004.php
The chief executive driving California's increasingly troubled campaign to build a high-speed rail system resigned Thursday, casting even greater uncertainty on the future of the $98 billion project.
Roelof van Ark, hired to lead the California High-Speed Rail Authority in May 2010, announced his resignation about four hours into an authority board meeting in Los Angeles.
"The time has come to focus myself more on my family and other interests," he said, citing the delivery of "an honest and realistic business plan," the award of $3.7 billion in federal funds and the scheduled start of construction on a 130-mile stretch of rail in the San Joaquin Valley this fall as accomplishments.
Van Ark's resignation was not the only change in the authority leadership announced Thursday. Tom Umberg, chairman of the authority board, said he will step down from that role next month, but remain on the board, and will nominate Dan Richard, former BART director from Oakland, to head the board.
The resignations come at a critical time for the project, which has come under increasing attack from critics and even one-time supporters. Last week, an independent panel of infrastructure experts recommended the Legislature not release bond funds for the project, and a recent Field Poll found the plan to connect the Bay Area and Southern California with fast trains losing public support.
Richard said van Ark's resignation was voluntary, and that the executive had planned to leave once the business plan was produced. Richard and other observers said van Ark, who has an international background in high-speed rail projects, may have been overwhelmed by the rigors of navigating state politics. ...
"East Japan Railway targets Californian high speed contracts." Railway Gazette International, 8 September 2014.(on line)
https://www.railwaygazette.com/east-japan-railway-targets-californian-high-speed-contracts/39946.article
USA: JR East is to lead a Japanese consortium in bidding for railway systems contracts for the Los Angeles – San Francisco high speed line now being developed by the California High Speed Rail Authority.
Samuel J. Levy, “Capacity Challenges on the California High-Speed Rail Shared Corridors: How Local Decisions Have Statewide Impacts.” Thesis, Master of Science in Transportation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, June 2015. (Discusses difficulties associated with blended operations.)
https://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/99542/925473327-MIT.pdf;sequence=1
"DB consortium selected for California high speed rail consultancy contract." Railway Gazette International, 9 October 2017. (on line)
https://www.railwaygazette.com/high-speed/db-consortium-selected-for-california-high-speed-rail-consultancy-contract/45284.article
USA: California High-Speed Rail Authority announced on October 6 that the DB Engineering & Consulting USA consortium has submitted the highest-scoring proposal for the Early Train Operator services contract.
The winner of the ETO contract would provide CHSRA with an operating perspective during the planning and procurement of civil works, rolling stock and facilities, with the aim of ensuring that the high speed line will be attractive to passengers while minimising operating and maintenance costs. ...
The highest-scored consortium comprises DB International USA, Deutsche Bahn, Alternate Concepts and HDR Inc.
The second-ranked proposal was submitted by a Spanish consortium of national operator RENFE Operadora and infrastructure manager ADIF, along with Globalvia Inversiones.
The third-ranked offer came from the FS First Rail Group, comprising Italian state railway group FS Italiane with operator Trenitalia and infrastructure manager RFI; CentoStazioni; UK operator First Group and consultancies Italferr and McKinsey & Co.
In fourth place came the China HSR ETO Consortium of China Railway International, Beijing Railway Administration, China Railway Eryuan Engineering Group and China Railway Corp.
David Castellon, "California, Texas riding different tracks to high-speed rail." The Business Journal, August 31, 2018 - 9:14 AM. (on line)
https://thebusinessjournal.com/california-texas-riding-different-tracks-to-high-speed-rail/
... When asked if the California program has ever asked for private investments, Annie Parker, a spo
kesperson for the California High-Speed Rail Authority, said private investment wasn’t needed early on once state voters approved the bond money, and now “In the business plan, we want to make sure we’re at the right section of the project to get that private investment.” ...
One thing officials with the authority don’t want to do is to wait to build the entire 520-mile line before seeking those investors.
Instead, Parker said, the goal is to finish construction of the 119-mile Central Valley Line and the 84-mile Silicon Valley Line and start service from San Francisco to Bakersfield to demonstrate passenger numbers and profitability to potential investors.When asked if the California program has ever asked for private investments, Annie Parker, a spokesperson for the California High-Speed Rail Authority, said private investment wasn’t needed early on once state voters approved the bond money, and now “In the business plan, we want to make sure we’re at the right section of the project to get that private investment.”
Once the “Valley-to-Valley” sections of the rail line are running and can be shown to be viable, “at that point the private sector would be a key factor in getting us down to Southern California,” with their investments helping fund that portion of the project, she said. ...
And once the line to Southern California is done, Keppler said, “Bakersfield would become a bedroom commuhe private sector would be a key factor in getting us down to Southern California,” with their investments helping fund that portion of the project, she said.nity of Los Angeles. It would explode.”
Ralph Vartabedian, “How California’s faltering high-speed rail project was ‘captured’ by costly consultants.” Los Angeles Times, April 26, 2019. (on line)
https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-california-high-speed-rail-consultants-20190426-story.html
“WSP, a Montreal-based international engineering firm, leads the state’s main consulting operation, Rail Delivery Partner.
“Formerly known as Parsons Brinckerhoff, WSP has been involved in many giant engineering works, some of which won awards and others that went far over budget and past deadline, including Boston’s troubled Big Dig, the Honolulu light rail project and a transit system in St. Louis.
“It is WSP that holds the lease on much of the office space at rail authority headquarters, supplies proprietary software that the authority uses and provides servers that store the project’s data. The firm also helps oversee three other consulting ventures that monitor construction teams — Wong-Harris for the Fresno area, Arcadis for Kings County and HNTB for Tulare County. (Each of those three consultants have teams of subconsultants who work under them.)
“In 2008, WSP developed the estimate that the Los Angeles-to-San Francisco line would cost $33 billion and take 12 years to build. In the same year, voters approved a $9-billion bond that was supposed to fund one-third of the project.
“ 'We listened to their estimates,' said Quentin Kopp, who was chairman of the rail board in 2008 but has since become an ardent critic. 'They were clearly wrong.' …
“WSP has stayed on the job for about a quarter of a century. It was given a new $700-million contract in 2015, despite warning signs that the project was headed for major cost overruns and had encountered serious delays.”
[Note; An accompanying table shows that WSP has received $666.4 million in contracts from CHSRA. It's not clear how much of this relates to the $700 million contract in 2015.]
"HSR: Top Democrats Signal their Support at an End." KMJNOW, July 30, 2019. (on line)
ttps://www.kmjnow.com/2019/07/30/hsr-top-democrats-signal-their-support-at-an-end/
FRESNO (KMJ) – More trouble for the embattled High Speed Rail project, as some big Democrats suggest their support for the Central Valley project may be at an end.
The Los Angeles times is reporting some key lawmakers want to shift billions of dollars from HSR’s Central Valley segment to rail projects in Southern California and the Bay Area. It’s an idea that could crush the dreams of HSR supporters.
Assembly Democrats say they see greater public value in improving passenger rail from Burbank to Anaheim, relieving congestion on the busy Interstate 5 corridor before the 2028 summer Olympics in LA, and putting additional money into San Francisco commuter rail.
Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon says, “any project that doesn’t have a significant amount of service to the largest areas in the state doesn’t make much sense.”
"Assemblyman Frazier frustrated with High Speed Rail Draft Business Plan full of misleading information." Contra Costa Herald, May 27, 2020. (on line)
http://contracostaherald.com/assemblyman-frazier-frustrated-with-high-speed-rail-draft-business-plan-full-of-misleading-information/
Sacramento – Earlier today ... the Assembly Transportation Committee Chaired by Assemblymember Jim Frazier (D-Fairfield) held an oversight hearing on the California High Speed Rail Authority’s (HSRA) 2020 Draft Business Plan. The HSRA is required to adopt and submit a final business plan to the Legislature on May 1st every two years that details funding, financing and ridership estimates for the entire project. ...
“Once again, it seems the High-Speed Rail Authority has released in the 2020 Draft Business Plan a proposal for its future that it can’t afford and that won’t deliver what is promised. Every version of the Business Plan has increased costs and reduced scope and no longer resembles the vision promised in the 2008 ballot measure’’, said Assemblymember Frazier. “Despite efforts by myself and some of my colleagues, the Authority continues to propose electrifying a segment of a train line in the Central Valley that will add billions of dollars to the project and provide little or no benefit.”
“I believe there is a way to rescue this project from failure, but I think it requires honest evaluation and true cost-benefit analysis, neither of which the Authority has ever been able to provide”, continued Frazier. “Every iteration of the business plan comes with new promises without results. It is going to take a lot of explanation for me to believe that, this time, the Authority’s cost and ridership estimates are legitimate, and this is something the state should continue to invest in.”
Ralph Vartabedian, "California’s scaled-back high-speed rail plan faces doubts amid financial crunch." Los Angeles Times, Sep. 8, 2020 5 AM. (on line)
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-09-08/newsom-bullet-train-faces-financial-crunch
It was just last year that Gov. Gavin Newsom said he would need to downsize California’s ambitious bullet train project, because the state could afford only a limited system from Merced to Bakersfield.
But even the viability of that scaled-down $20.4-billion plan is becoming uncertain as construction costs rise in the San Joaquin Valley, expected revenues are under pressure and land acquisition problems continue to mount.
The changing conditions have prompted the California High-Speed Rail Authority to launch a comprehensive reassessment of its plans, said Chief Executive Brian Kelly, who is facing tougher questions by state leaders, given the austere outlook.
“I just want the truth,” said Assembly Transportation Chairman Jim Frazier (D-Discovery Bay), a former general contractor who has grown distrustful of the project’s planning. “I want an independent analysis of what can be accomplished and how much it is going to cost.”
Contractors for the rail authority are filing massive change orders and delay claims, according to disclosures by the agency and internal documents obtained by The Times. Additional land is also needed, adding to costs. ...
Cumulatively, the increased costs and decreased revenues are saddling Newsom’s plan with a potential fiscal hole of more than $1 billion. At the same time, some valley property owners are growing increasingly frustrated, having waited for years to be compensated for their land and endured disruptions caused by construction.
The project will face a tough hurdle if weak revenues and rising costs drive a request for more money to just complete the San Joaquin Valley construction, Frazier said.
Frazier still supports the concept of high-speed rail but is blunt that the public “is getting less and it is costing more” and “there is a point of no return, obviously.”
The impacts of COVID-19 are forcing the rail authority’s reassessment, Kelly said. The money to execute the entire Los Angeles-to-San Francisco project was never in hand, and the state has incrementally managed the project, step by step, the agency’s CEO said.
The new assessment, he said, is examining four issues: revenues, costs, project scope and the schedule, resulting in a pause in finalizing the 2020 business plan. Any changes would be submitted to the rail authority board and then the governor, Kelly said.
“Challenges come,” he added. “It is part of life, the global pandemic.”
No comments:
Post a Comment