Proposition 1A , the "Safe, Reliable High-Speed Passenger Train Bond Act for the 21st Century," was approved by California voters in November 2008. A major selling point was the prospect of attracting outside funding from the federal government and private investors, leveraged by a state contribution of $9 billion in bond sales authorized by the measure. Thus far, this hasn't worked out very well; the current construction project in the Central Valley from Madera to Shafter is projected to cost $11.7 billion, of which only $2.1 B (17%) comes from a federal ARRA grant. The rest of the funding is entirely from state sources: $2.6 B (23%) from Prop. 1A bonds and about $7 B (60%) from Greenhouse Gas Cap & Trade revenue. The federal contribution is disappointing, and there's no private partner.
Why so little interest by potential partners in the California HSR Project? It's mainly because the CHSR Authority is committed to an exorbitantly expensive route connecting Los Angeles and Bakersfield via Palmdale which requires 40 miles of tunneling. In its 2005 programmic EIR, the CHSRA claimed that this route would need only 13 miles, compared to 23 miles of tunneling for the alternative, direct route across Tejon pass (I-5). The Authority selected the Palmdale route as the "Preferred Alternative" for two reasons; its estimated cost was slightly less than the direct I-5 route, but the decisive factor for the CHSRA was potential development in the Antelope valley served by a Palmdale station.
Los Angeles anchors the California HSR Project, and a connection to northern California across the Tehachapi mountains is essential to generate an acceptable level of ridership and revenue for the project. But the link via Palmdale is far too expensive to attract outside funding; its cost is now well over $30 billion, more than twice the estimated cost in the 2005 EIR ($14 B, after adjusting for inflation). No one is willing to buy into this exorbitantly expensive venture. The obvious alternative is the direct route across Tejon pass, which was considered in the 2005 EIR but set aside in favor of the longer alignment. If the CHSR Authority honestly wants a public-private partnership, the selection of the Preferred Alternative has to be reconsidered: the only serious proposals from potential partners will involve the direct link across Tejon pass.
No comments:
Post a Comment