California HSR should use Tejon Pass

The current California HSR plan has significant flaws; a major mistake was selecting a detour via Palmdale instead of the direct route via I-5 across Tejon pass to connect Bakersfield to Los Angeles. The cost of the Palmdale route -- about $32 billion in current dollars -- is more than twice that of the direct link, and nobody wants to pay for it. The HSR project will be restricted to the Central Valley until the less expensive Tejon route is embraced.

Thursday, May 15, 2014

Summary of candidates' views on HSR
from Sacramento Bee survey

The Sacramento Bee conducted a survey of the positions of candidates running in the June 3th primary election on a selected number of issues, including the California high speed rail project (see previous post on this blog). Candidates for governor, nine assembly seats, and three senate seats in the Sacramento region were asked whether they supported the current plan, and what should be done next with the project. A total of 51 candidates were included in this group.

Here is a summary of the candidates' responses to the first question: California is seeking to build the first high-speed rail system in the nation. Do you agree or disagree with this plan?

                             Dem  Rep Other
Strongly disagree             1   16    4
Disagree                      3    3    3
Neither agree nor disagree    0    1    0
Agree                        10    0    0
Strongly agree                2    0    0
No response                   3    4    1

As might be expected, there is a striking difference between the views of candidates from the two major parties. Candidates otherwise affiliated are a mixed bag (including at least two on the left), but are largely negative about the HSR project. Gov. Brown declined to answer specific questions, but he should probably be added to the "strongly agree" category. Some Democratic candidates "disagree" with the HSR plan, and even those who "agree" expressed misgivings about where it is headed. Responses to the second question included these comments:

  • "... it will serve only a relatively few Californians and create nowhere near the number of jobs predicted." (Rodriguez, Gov.)
  • "Gov. Brown must engage private sector ... to make this project a reality in a sensible time frame." (Jawahar, SD 4)
  • "We need to ensure that this project gets back on track and work to keep the costs down." (Pan, SD 6)
  • "The state needs to get the financing of the project in order." (Reed, AD 3)
  • "Today’s high-speed rail project is substantially different than the plan narrowly approved by California voters in 2008." (Gallagher, AD 3)
  • "Management for the project needs to show a business plan that is realistic." (Dodd, AD 4)
  • "More must be done to control costs and ensure public benefit." (Krovoza, AD 4)
  • "... it needs to be implemented wisely and cost-effectively." (Wolk, AD 4)
  • "... our focus should be on upgrading existing rail service such as Capitol Corridor." (Cohn, AD 7)
  • "... we should focus first on existing high-volume routes, like Sacramento to San Francisco ..." (McCarty, AD 7)
  • ... this idea is badly timed and its costs are greater than we can bear now." (Cooley, AD 8)
  • "We need to streamline the bureaucracy and look at a better, more cost-efficient route." (Cooper, AD 9)
  • "... a rail system will only work if it is taking people to places they want to go ... [such as] along heavily traveled freeway routes." (Fong, AD 9
  • "... the Legislature needs to be more actively involved in providing oversight." (Rodriguez-Suruki, AD 9)

No comments:

Post a Comment