From the Sacramento Bee, May 11, 2014
California is seeking to build the first high-speed rail system in the nation. Do you agree or disagree with this plan? What should the state do next with the high-speed rail program? Explain.
Governor
Tim Donnelly (R): Strongly disagree. Terminate the high-speed rail and build a high-speed waterway and implement a statewide water plan that respects each region of the state.
Neel Kashkari (R): Strongly disagree. Cancel the crazy train! It’s the best example of Gov. Brown’s misplaced priorities at a time when California ranks #47 in jobs, #46 in education, #1 in poverty and we’re facing a massive drought. Building a $67 billion legacy project makes no sense.
Jerry Brown (D): Declined to respond.
Cindy Sheehan (P): Disagree. I think the funds should be used to expand inexpensive public transportation such as more bus (that run on clean, renewable energy sources) lines, expand BART and LA METRO (i.e.) into more suburbs; increase protected bike and pedestrian paths, etc.
Akinyemi O. Agbede (R): Candidate response is not yet available.
Richard Aquirre (R): Strongly disagree. We need to focus on getting our basic needs like power, water and the food supply under control before we endeavor into things like this rail system. Read my New California Prosperity Plan to see how Californians can save our economy and culture.
Bo Ambrozewicz (I): Strongly disagree. I will repeal the train to nowhere. It is already doubled over budget. We should use these funds to solve the water issue.
Andrew Blount (R): Disagree. High-speed rail has been in the pipeline for nearly 20 years. It's time to reevaluate the use of the funds and ensure that this is still the correct infrastructure project to spend them on, then actually build the resulting project.
Janel Buycks (I): Disagree. I do not believe establishing this program would benefit California, but instead kill some small businesses, as it's not clear as to who will have access to these jobs and who will oversee this project to ensure that Californians have jobs.
Glenn Champ (R): Strongly disagree. Terminate and redirect the funds and redirect to water storage.
Rakeshkumar Christian (App): Strongly disagree. Hold it for future until state must balance the budget. First several other problems like energy, electricity. Electricity is the priority. Common sense.
Joseph E. Leicht (I): Strongly disagree. Ultimately we have to determine what is the best use of the taxpayers' money. Could the estimated $97 billion be better used for education, funding our public employees' retirement, for example? Why throw good money after bad?
Robert C. Newman II (I): Strongly disagree. Abandon the boondoggle. It is little more than a scheme to get the taxpayers to pay for buying the votes of corporate and union contributors to big-government candidates.
Luis J. Rodriguez (Grn): Disagree. It should be canceled as it will serve only a relatively few Californians and create nowhere near the number of jobs predicted. The money should go to expanding and eco-fitting existing urban and rural transit systems that working people rely upon.
Alma Marie Winston (R): Strongly disagree. Clearly, this is NOT the right time to invest in a railway train, due to more pressing concerns of State.
State Senate 4
CJ Jawahar (D): Agree. I believe in growth and infrastructure development" to modernize California. Gov. Brown must engage private sector to bring in funds, like in Texas and Florida, besides public funds and bonds to make this project a reality in a sensible time frame.
Jim Nielsen (R): Strongly disagree. Not one more dime should be spent on "high speed rail." The voters of California were mislead by HSR advocates about cost estimates, ridership, and taking private property. We must redirect this money to building water storage for all Californians.
State Senate 6
Roger Dickinson (D): Agree. We must meet our growing transportation demand for the future. High speed rail will create tens of thousands of jobs, is environmentally friendly, and is the most cost-effective approach.
Richard Pan (D): Agree. High speed rail will create infrastructure jobs; however, the program has experienced too many delays and cost overruns. We need to ensure that this project gets back on track and work to keep the costs down.
James Axelgard (R): Declined to respond
Jonathan Zachariou (R): Strongly disagree. True high speed rail would be great! Siemens is selling California a train that has been used in Europe for 30+ years that will be completed in 2033, 50 Billion over Prop 1A limit. 60 MPH faster than AMTRAK? It's Europe's leftovers! We can do better
State Senate 8
Tom Berryhill (R): Did not respond
Paulina Miranda (D): Agree. Continue with a project to connect the mega-regions: with a diverse variety of employment, a construction management contract of $40-60 million: 30 percent assigned for small business participation, women firms, disadvantage business, and veterans.
State Assembly 1
Brian Dahle (R): Disagree. Re-evaluate the entire project based upon new information that has become available. Other infrastructure needs are more important, roads and water storage being first on the list.
Brigham Sawyer Smith (D): Candidate response is not yet available.
State Assembly 3
Jim Reed (D): Agree. The state needs to get the financing of the project in order.
James Gallagher (R): Strongly disagree. Today’s high-speed rail project is substantially different than the plan narrowly approved by California voters in 2008. We should not spend another penny on this boondoggle, and the Legislature must give voters another chance to weigh in.
Ryan Schohr (R): Strongly disagree. Abandon it. Our state has an unfunded pension liability that grows by the millions each day and an unemployment rate that remains over the federal average. The rail will do nothing to solve the real challenges faced by both our state and taxpayers.
State Assembly 4
Bill Dodd (D): Disagree. Management for the project needs to show a business plan that is realistic. If it cannot show one grounded in fiscal reality or credibility, it should be stopped.
Joe Krovoza (D): Agree. In principle, I support the concept of high speed rail to reduce carbon emissions and to increase travel choice. However, I have major concerns about how it is implemented in California. More must be done to control costs and ensure public benefit.
Dustin Call (R): Candidate response is not yet available.
Charles Schaupp (R): Strongly disagree. The high-speed rail plan is a huge example of governmental folly and mismanagement. It has become a multibillion dollar boondoggle we cannot afford. It needs to be stopped now and completely re-evaluated for feasibility and fiscal responsibility.
Dan Wolk (D): Strongly agree. I'm a proponent of public transportation and reinvesting in public infrastructure - and carrying out the will of the voters - so I am a proponent of high-speed rail. That said, it needs to be implemented wisely and cost-effectively.
State Assembly 5
Frank Bigelow (R): Strongly disagree. Repurpose high-speed rail funds and implement the Assembly Republican caucus plan to dedicate $11 billion in one-time funds and $2.4 billion annually for statewide transportation infrastructure needs which would create 108,000 new California jobs.
State Assembly 6
Brian Caples (D): Agree. Expand it to increase access for my district. I will work with the Democratic Party to make sure my voters benefit by expanding the rail to include routes to Reno and Lake Tahoe - with stops in major cities in between to reduce traffic on the 50/80.
Beth Gaines (R): Strongly disagree. The bullet train to nowhere is a boondoggle. I support a plan to send the program back to voters with the money going to local infrastructure needs when it is voted down.
State Assembly 7
Steve Cohn (D): Strongly disagree. I support high-speed rail in principle, but our focus should be on upgrading existing rail service such as Capitol Corridor. With appropriate investments, we can attain "higher" speed rail such as a one-hour ride between Sacramento and San Francisco.
Mark Johannessen (D): Strongly agree. Steps should be taken to ensure that the bonds associated with this plan are sold in a timely fashion, that private investors are encouraged to provide funding by making it easy for them to do so, and the cost to tax payers is minimized.
Kevin McCarty (D): Agree. I agree with the vision of high-speed rail. However, we should focus first on existing high-volume routes, like Sacramento to San Francisco, San Francisco to San Jose and Los Angeles to San Diego.
Ralph Merletti (R): Neither agree nor disagree. More studies. The focus should be on our immediate transportation needs: state and local highways, some of which are in great need of repair and upgrading. CA 99 should be given full U.S. interstate status from Red Bluff to south of Bakersfield.
Oliver Ponce (R): Disagree. The notion of constructing a high speed rail to improve mobility around the state is a novel notion, but it remains just that - a novel idea. The large price tag is too much to thrust onto taxpayers.
State Assembly 8
Janice Marlae Bonser (L): Candidate response is not yet available.
Ken Cooley (D): Disagree. Having a mobile workforce is vital to California job growth. But this idea is badly timed and its costs are greater than we can bear now. In the future it would help us; a strong transit backbone helped the Bay Area recover from current downturn.
Doug Haaland (R): Strongly disagree. As recently reported, the high-speed rail system will not be able to meet the voter-approved trip times that make it eligible to receive state bond funds. It must be scrapped and funding applied to current transportation and water needs of the State.
State Assembly 9
Jim Cooper (D): Agree. While I applaud the goal of taking cars off the road and job creation, we need to bring some accountability to this program. We need to streamline the bureaucracy and look at a better, more cost-efficient route.
Darrell Fong (D): Disagree. I voted for high-speed rail. Maybe I am being simplistic, but a rail system will only work if it is taking people to places they want to go. I think that would have been better achieved by routing rail along heavily traveled freeway routes.
Tim Gorsulowsky (R): Strongly disagree. The high-speed rail program should not proceed at this time in California. California needs to focus on promoting the business sector back to the state to increase our revenue. Also, develop an alternate plan for water supply to farmers and people.
Manuel J. Martin (R): Strongly disagree. The state should end the high-speed rail. Transportation of people by trains is the technology of the 1800's. We progressed towards cars and planes for means of transportation. Reinvest the money in our roads and infrastructure.
Diana Rodriguez-Suruki (D): Agree. I support a high speed rail system for California. However, the Legislature needs to be more actively involved in providing oversight. As an assemblywoman, I would provide more oversight over the project and engage other legislators to do the same. How important is this issue to you?
State Assembly 11
Jim Frazier (D): Candidate response is not yet available.
Alex M. Henthorn (R): Strongly disagree. The state should end the waste on high-speed rail and instead focus on investing in existing infrastructure. We should be modernizing our airports while making needed repairs to our roads. These investments will make our state attractive to business.
No comments:
Post a Comment