To Noel Braymer, 4/22/12
Included in RailPAC Weekly E-Newsletter, April 30, 2012
The HSR Authority probably realizes that it isn't likely to get additional federal grants for at least ten years. That's probably the main reason it's moving ahead with "blended" operations in the urban areas, so it can use local funds to match Prop. 1-A bonds. This is fine with me -- a modern, electric rail line from Lancaster to Laguna Niguel (outer limits) is a much better project to demonstrate modern rail service project than a stranded Fresno-to-Bakerfield segment -- but I would still prefer to see some progress in closing the Bakersfield-Palmdale gap.
I also think that the HSR Authority is evading a couple of fundamental questions -- if the rest of the Prop. 1-A bonds are chewed up by construction in the urban areas, what happens to the overall HSR project? And don't the restrictive conditions written into Prop. 1-A -- construction to 220 mph standards, alignments through Pachecho and Tehachapi passes, 2:40 running time between SF and LA -- effectively disappear once the Prop. 1-A bonds are exhausted? It seems to me that the project will then have to be completely re-evaluated, and again that isn't a bad outcome. But the state will arrive at this point with three isolated HSR segments, and unable to connect them short of another public vote to authorize more state bonds.
Since this point is not likely to be reached for another 15 years, what other, less expensive intercity rail options should be pursued in the meantime? I've felt for some time that the Daylight option on the Coast is a good, relatively inexpensive alternative to the Central Valley route for SF-LA service in the short-term. With a relatively modest investment -- perhaps $5 billion, but that's peanuts compared to the cost of the Valley alignment -- the SF-LA running time along the Coast could be reduced to as little as 6 hours. And this service could run electric in the urban areas (using dual-power locs), which automatically helps to improve train performance. Through-running from San Diego (which I understand you'd like to see) would also be automatic. But it won't help me a lot (Sac-LA), which will still require a bus bridge (Bakersfield-Newhall) for a long time into the future.
No comments:
Post a Comment