To Noel Braymer, 4/8/12
Included in RailPAC Weekly E-Newsletter, April 16, 2012
You've probably seen the op-ed piece in today's (4/8) Sac Bee by Daniel Carson discussing the dismal prospects of funding the California HSR project. The piece is interesting because it is not overtly anti-HSR, but sticks to pointing out the financial fantasies concocted to support rapid completion of the IOS and the "Bay to Basin" plan. Carson's views are, in fact, very close to my own.
To be fair, there are some positive aspects to the latest version of the HSR plan: designating the Tehachapi crossing as the next segment to be built, and undertaking to improve existing passenger rail lines with a view towards implementing "blended" HSR services where appropriate. But funding of these improvements is even hazier than funding HSR itself.
What is missing in the debate about HSR is an understanding that modernization of existing rail services at some reasonable speed is much less expensive than the full-blown HSR option built to 220-mph standards. Moderization would include full grade separtation (from roads) and almost complete separation from freight operations, to allow running of diesel passenger trains up to 125 mph and electric trains up to 150 mph. The target should be a running time of under 5 hours from the Bay Area to Los Angeles, and a half-hour less for Sacramento-L.A.
The 220-mph system should be deferred to the far future, and the state should concentrate on improving existing services plus the Tehachapi crossing. The current federal funding of about $3.3 billion, plus an equal match from Prop. 1-A bonds, gives the state $6.6 billion to start with. The state should renegotiate its federal contract to build the Fresno-Bakersfield segment as rapidly as possible (to a 150-mph standard), using up the federal grant to meet the 2017 deadline. The state bonds would then be devoted to building the Tehachapi crossing, starting with the Bakersfield-Tehachapi segment and perhaps even reaching the L.A. county line to link up with Metrolink.
Concurrently, the existing Metrolink Antelope Valley and the Orange County lines would be moderized, so that electric service could be operated from Irvine to Fresno (300 miles) by 2020. This is a practical alternative to the currently proposed IOS, and should cost no more than $10 billion.
Many thanks for the notes you publish every week -- I look forward to reading them.
No comments:
Post a Comment