Before the CA state senate vote on July 6th I thought that the federal stimulus grant for HSR would be better spent in the Los Angeles Basin, but after the vote I've changed my mind. It's better to have a somewhat over-built segment from Madera to Bakersfield that can run at speeds close to 200 mph than to have a segment centered on LAUS that may be limited to 150 mph or possibly only 125. This sort of practical limit on speeds in urban areas was acknowledged by the CHSR Authority in its recent business plan, which recommends operating high speed trains both in the L.A. Basin and in the Bay Area initially on the same tracks as conventional passenger trains ("blended" operations). The additional $1 billion-plus authorized by the state legislature for blended operations in L.A. will cover a large portion of the costs of this project, particularly if it is matched by local (Metrolink) money.
For this assignment of federal funds to the San Joaquin Valley to be effective, the Authority must adopt the Merced to San Fernando scenario for Phase 1 of HSR, giving priority to the Tehachapi crossing (per RailPAC's adopted position). But there is a serious flaw in Prop 1A, which mandates a detour through Palmdale and across Tehachapi pass. The cost of this alternative has now gone through the roof: about $16 billion for Bakersfield-Palmdale-San Fernando compared to a $7 billion estimate in the 2005 EIR! Presumably, the cost of the I-5 (Tejon pass) alternative has not seen so dramatic an escalation, but the Authority is apparently forbidden by Prop 1A to revisit this option. The legislature needs to clarify Prop 1A to allow Tejon pass to be considered as an alternative to the now prohibitively expensive Palmdale routing.
This small change to Prop 1A is absolutely essential in order to move forward with a relatively inexpensive Phase 1 using Prop 1A bonds. The cost of the I-5 alternative presented in the 2005 EIR was about $8 billion (current dollars), which is sufficiently small to legitimately ask for half-share federal funding in a single grant for a project of this importance. With improvements to the Metrolink/Surfliner corridor in the L.A. Basin, Phase 1 of HSR construction would effectively provide an initial operating segment for HSR from Merced to Anaheim, a distance of over 300 miles!
References:
Final Program EIR/EIS Report: Volume 3: Appendix 4-C, "Capital Cost: High Speed Train Alternative" (CHSR Authority, 2005).
Revised 2012 Business Plan Source Documents: "Cost Changes from 2009 Report to 2012 Business Plan" (CHSR Authority, 2012)
No comments:
Post a Comment