Portions of this post appear in RailPAC Weekly E-Newsletter, July 9, 2012.
Most of the federal rail stimulus money awarded to California ($3.3 billion) should be shifted from the San Joaquin Valley to the urban areas -- chiefly the Los Angeles basin. NARP opposes this shift, calling construction of HSR in urban areas mere "enhancements of conventional infrastructure" (Hotline #765 -- June 29, 2012), but this position ignores the evolution of how to implement about HSR in California's urban areas. The original California proposal for federal funding included a request for a $2.2 billion grant for HSR between L.A. and Anaheim, matched by another $2.2 B of Prop. 1-A bonds. The CHSR Authority now plans to substantially upgrade existing urban rail corridors, so that (for example) high speed trains in the L.A. basin can share tracks with Pacific Surfliner and Metrolink services. The revised proposal would implement this "blended" system, at less than half the cost of full HSR. This plan would provide immediate benefits to the most important rail corridor in the U.S. outside the Northeast Corridor, and prepare the way for an HSR system operating across the Tehachapis to Bakersfield (preferably via Tejon pass).
The combination of a new rail crossing of the Tehachapis with rail improvements in the L.A. Basin is the single most important rail project in the entire U.S., generating more new intercity rail ridership than is current carried on the Northeast Corridor (about 15 million per year, compared to 12 million). The total cost of this projec, extending from Bakersfield to Anaheim (or Irvine), is around $15 billion, well within the funding capability of Prop. 1-A bonds together with matching federal grants. And it far outperforms any other option for HSR in California at a comparable cost. The bottom line is that the Tehachapi crossing is the single indispensable segment in a viable north-south rail line through the San Joaquin Valley, and details of extensions in the Vally should be deferred until the initial segment is in place. In the meantime, existing rail services at both ends of the HSR segment will serve as feeder lines with the possibility of offering run-through services such as Sacramento-San Diego.
One reason for initially limiting HSR in California to a relatively short system is that there are a large number of other rail projects that must also be carried forward, such as modernization of the Caltrain and ACE corridors in the north. Rail planners now think that "Super ACE" is the most important passenger rail project in the north, even if built to accommodate diesel operations at a maximum speed of 110 mph. Moreover, Super ACE can potentially provide San Joaquin service from San Francisco to Bakersfield at a run time of around 4 hours (average speed of 75 mph). But building HSR in northern California in advance of the Tehachapi crossing is almost a complete waste of money.
More broadly, the California HSR project as defined in Prop. 1-A is effectively a dead letter because of ballooning costs. The total cost for the entire 800-mile project now stands at some $150 billion and the $9 billion authorized by Prop. 1-A cannot realistically leverage more than a minimal initial segment. But the planning effort has been useful in some regards: we now have a more solid appreciation of the costs, ridership, and benefits of improved passenger rail in California, and the realization that it is impossible to effectively plan and finance this large of a project in the scattershot fashion allowed (and even encouraged) by mandates written into Prop. 1-A.
Building an anchor in the L.A. Basin is clearly the best place to start the California HSR system, since it provides immediate benefits (improved Pacific Surfliner and Metrolink services) that a stranded HSR line in the San Joaquin Valley cannot come close to matching. By starting in the L.A. Basin, the state can legitimately pursue federal funding for the Tehachapi crossing, using what is left of Prop. 1-A bonds for the local match. This is probably all California can afford to spend on HSR in the next 20 years, but coupled with greatly improved San Joaquin service (and possibly run-through trains to Los Angeles) it provides a clear goal that is much more likely to succeed than the dim prospects for the current, unfocused efforts.
Comment by Noel Braymer, Newsletter editor:
Since we can't take taxpayers money for granted we need to get as much out of what we get and serve as many people with it as possible. Each time we have a winner for rail service the more likely we will have support to build more improvements.
No comments:
Post a Comment